Sec 57 to continue as ‘govt safeguard’

0
122

ICT-Act11Dhaka: The much-talked about Section 57 of the Information and Communication Technology (Amendment) Act, 2013 will not be withdrawn. It would be used as a “safeguard” of the government, a senior minister told The Independent yesterday.

Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina said this at yesterday’s cabinet meeting, he noted.

Without Section 57, it will not be possible to tackle cyber crime, and there would be a rise in such incidents, the minister quoted the PM as having said.

The section is used against those who spread fabricated news, Sheikh Hasina told the meeting.

The senior minister said Hasina advised information minister Hasanul Haque Inu to hold a meeting with stakeholders and point out that it is harmful to the media.

At the Cabinet meeting, agriculture minister Matia Chowdhury, education minister Nurul Islam Nahid, law minister Anisul Huq, state minister for telecommunications Tarana Halim, state minister for ICT Zunaid Ahmed Palak, principal secretary Kamal Abdul Naser Chowdhury and National Board of Revenue (NBR) chairman Nazibur Rahman claimed that some newspapers had published baseless news against them.

Nurul Islam Nahid told his cabinet colleagues that the owner of a Bengali newspaper sent one of his correspondents to his office to lobby for certain things.

“When I turned down their request, they wrote a series of baseless reports against me,”

the education minister said.

Nazibur Rahman said he too was a “victim” of the Bengali newspaper. It published a series of reports against him.

Kamal Abdul Naser Chowdhury said an online newspaper and a weekly magazine did the same when he did not pay heed to a request of the owner and editor.

 After hearing their grievances, the Prime Minister told them to file cases against the newsmen for publishing baseless reports under Section 57 of the ICT Act.

Section 57 of the ICT (Amendment) Act, 2013 says if any person deliberately publishes any material in the electronic form that causes law and order to deteriorate, prejudices the image of the state or a person or causes hurt to religious belief, the offender will be punished for a maximum of 14 years and a minimum of seven years of imprisonment. It also suggested that the crime be non-bailable.

 At the meeting, Tarana Halim and Zunaid Ahmed Palak explained the proposed Digital Security Act.

Section 19 of the proposed Act contains most of what is present in Section 57 of the ICT Act.

Under the draft Digital Security Act, if any person deliberately publishes any material in the electronic form that causes law and order to deteriorate, prejudices the image of the state or a person or causes hurt to religious belief, the offender will be punished for a maximum of two years of rigorous imprisonment and face a fine of up to Tk. 2 lakh, or both.

 “Defamation cases would be tried under the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC), 1860. To tackle cyber crimes, the new law would have provisions for punishment of a maximum of 14 years in jail for offenders,” the proposed law added.

 The Editors’ Council has demanded that the government withdraw Article 57 from the ICT Act and not take the initiative to include the article in any new law. It has said that the article is contradictory to the Constitution and a threat to freedom of expression, as laid down in the charter, and also a threat to journalists.

 “We are concerned that Article 19 of the proposed Digital Security Act contains all the clauses present in Article 57 of the ICT Act. Article 19 specially contains clauses concerning so-called libel and attempt to socially humiliate,” a member of the council said.

 The state minister for ICT, Zunaid Ahmed Palak, had earlier said that the proposed law would be enacted to tackle cyber crimes.

 He said the new law was necessary to protect people from false news or information. “After the new law is formulated, it will be possible to ensure trial of cyber criminals. It will be an elaborate version of the previously planned law, the ‘Cyber Security Act’, prepared by the ministry,” he added.

Earlier on July 9, Law Minister Anisul Huq said that the draft of the Digital Security Act would finalise by next month (August) and the much-talked about section 57 of Information Communication and Technology (ICT) Act would remain in force until the finalization of the Digital Security Act.

 “We will hold a final meeting on the issue in mid August to finalise it,” the minister came up with the remark while talking to reporters after holding a view exchange meeting on proposed Digital Security Act at the secretariat in Dhaka.

 The meeting was attended by Zunaid Ahmed Palak, State Minister for ICT Division and State Minister for Post and Telecommunications Tarana Halim among others.

 If the government even scraps the section 57, a similar provision is going to return in the proposed Digital Security Act approved by the cabinet last August.

 According to the law ministry sources, the government is going to replace Section 57 of the Information and Communication Technology (Amendment) Act, 2013 with Section 19 of the new Digital Security Act.

Many of the participants proposed the incorporation of a section in the Digital Security Act by simplifying Section 57 of the ICT Act to ensure freedom of expression, sources added.

 Sources also said that four provisions—Sections 54 to 57—would be deleted from the ICT Act and included in the Digital Security Act.

They also said the inter-ministerial committee would hold final meeting next month to finalise the Digital Security Act.

 Law minister Anisul Huq had earlier said that Section 57 of the Information and Communication Technology (ICT) Act would be scrapped and merged with a new Digital Security Act.

In recent statement, Newspapers Owners’ Association of Bangladesh (NOAB) has urged the government not to make any law, which would prevent the freedom of expression and curb the independence of newspapers. The association also demanded withdrawal of all cases filed against journalists under the controversial Section 57 of the Information and Communication Technology (ICT) Act.

The association leaders also demanded that the government refrain from taking any initiative to reintroduce similar provisions in any new law as these go against the constitution and serve as a threat to the freedom of speech and journalism that is guaranteed by the constitution.

Earlier, on July 21, the Editors’ Council had also expressed concern over the draft Digital Security Act and demanded repealing of the Section 57 of the ICT Act.